Does your earn-out drive the right behaviour, or just the price? What ours did to the deal, the team and the founder, and six questions to ask before you sign.
When Comma Group was sold in 2021, the buyer's opening position was a four-year earn-out.
We got it down to two. It was one of the most important things we negotiated, and I didn't fully understand why until I was living inside it.
An earn-out is the part of the price you are paid later, if the business hits agreed targets after the sale. Buyers use it to share risk. If the business performs, you get paid. If it doesn't, they've paid less for something worth less.
On paper, that's fair. In practice, it does something most founders don't plan for. It keeps you in the business, on someone else's terms, with your money tied to numbers you no longer fully control.
Most earn-out advice covers the mechanics. This piece is about what the earn-out does to the people: the founder, the team, and the customers who are still relying on both.
I'd seen an earn-out before. In year three, a private equity roll-up made us an offer. The number was big, and most of it was earn-out. An adviser told me plainly that a lot of it was tied to targets we probably wouldn't hit. We turned it down. That story is in You pay for the result.
So when the right buyer came along, I knew the earn-out mattered as much as the price.
Two years instead of four was the first win. Year one was contingent on revenue and EBITDA. If we hit the numbers, we got paid. If we didn't, we didn't.
We hit them. Then the buyer did something I hadn't expected. They made year two non-contingent. The money was no longer tied to performance, so the integration could finally start.
That one change told me more about earn-outs than anything I'd read.
Buyers use earn-outs for two different jobs. It helps to know which one you're being offered.
The first job is price. Buyer and seller disagree on what the business is worth, and the earn-out bridges the gap. Hit the numbers and you've proved your valuation. It motivates the founder to push performance.
The second job is retention. The buyer needs the founder, and often the key people, to stay through the handover. The earn-out keeps them in their seats.
The trouble starts when one mechanism tries to do both. Performance targets pull you towards this year's numbers. A good handover means helping the buyer change things, and change can cost this year's numbers.
Looking back, year two going non-contingent was the switch from one job to the other. Year one proved the price. Year two was about the handover, and once the money stopped depending on targets, the arguments stopped too.
Here is the part nobody puts in the heads of terms.
The day you sign, you stop being the owner. You're still the founder, and the team still looks to you. But the business belongs to someone else, and part of your payment depends on how it performs in their hands.
That creates a tension that's hard to describe until you're in it. The buyer wants to integrate: new systems, new reporting, new ways of working. Integration is why they bought you. But integration costs time and focus, and it can dent the very numbers your earn-out is measured on.
So the structure quietly turns you into the person resisting change. Not because you're difficult, but because you're paid to protect this year's revenue and EBITDA. In year one, the buyer wanted to integrate and I pushed back hard. Looking back, I was defending the earn-out as much as the business.
It is a strange place to stand. You built the thing. You chose the buyer. And now the deal you signed has made you their opponent on the decisions that matter most.
Year one was harder than the sale itself. You find out quickly which decisions are no longer yours. Every one of them feels personal, because you're still the face of the business to your team and your customers.
When year two went non-contingent, the emotion went out of it. The arguments stopped being about money. But by then I'd mentally checked out. I saw out the earn-out, and left in September 2023.
Then came the part I was least ready for. For five years I had been the person who ran Comma, and then I wasn't. I worked through that afterwards. I wish I'd started before. The earn-out delays the identity question. It doesn't answer it.
An earn-out isn't only between the founder and the buyer. Everyone in the business lives inside it too.
Your team feels the pull from both sides. The new owner is asking for change. The founder they've followed for years is slowing it down. They don't see the earn-out terms. They just see two sets of priorities and have to pick one.
Your customers feel it as well, even if they never hear the word. Integration delayed is service improvement delayed. The benefits the buyer promised them wait until the numbers are safe.
The financial structures of a deal sometimes get in the way of the right thing to do for the business and its customers.
That's the uncomfortable truth about earn-outs. They're designed to protect the buyer's price. They're not designed to protect the people in the middle.
One thing helped us. Once heads of terms were agreed, we ran an integration workstream alongside due diligence, before the SPA was signed. Both teams knew each other before the deal closed. That goodwill carried us through the harder months. It didn't remove the tension, but it meant the tension stayed professional.
The shorter earn-out was the right call. It meant two years of tension, not four. It also meant the integration, and everything the business and its customers gained from it, could start years sooner.
But the length was only half of it. The real lesson was that an earn-out is a people decision dressed up as a financial one. It decides who is in charge, who is pulling which way, and how long the founder stays in a business they no longer own.
If you're preparing to sell, think about the earn-out long before anyone offers you one. Know what you'd accept, what you'd walk away from, and what you want your life to look like when it ends.
The highest offer isn't always the best deal. Compare the routes in Exit Options, and see your Valuation and Exit Structure inside The Founders Exit®. Start free.
This article reflects one founder's experience and is not financial, legal or tax advice. Talk to a qualified adviser before agreeing deal terms.
Your Exit Readiness score and valuation range in about 15 minutes. Free, private, no card.